11 Ways To Make Your Protein Shake Taste Better

Last Updated on Mar 17, 2024 by HappyDieter

Do you like the benefits of drinking your workout drink, but hate the taste? Here are some ways to make your protein shake taste better you’ll look forward to!

Key Takeaways

  • Enhance the Visual Appeal: By garnishing your protein shake with fruits, nuts, or seeds, you can make it more visually appealing and enticing to drink.

  • Maintain Coolness: Keeping your protein shake chilled not only improves its taste but also makes it refreshing, especially on hot days.

  • Adjust the Concentration: Diluting your protein shake with more liquid can help tone down the strong flavors, making it more palatable.

  • Opt for Milk: Using milk instead of water can add creaminess and richness to your protein shake, enhancing its overall taste.

  • Choose Your Preferred Flavor: Selecting a protein powder flavor that you enjoy can significantly impact the taste of your shake, making it more enjoyable to consume.

  • Sweeten it Up: Adding natural sweeteners like honey or maple syrup can balance out any bitterness in the protein shake, making it more pleasant to drink.

Photo by Pixabay

1. Make it LOOK Better

When you see how delicious something looks, you just want to eat it. That is why food advertisements and menu photos have such a huge impact on us. If you want to make your next drink taste better, try making it look more appealing to eat. Use a uniquely shaped glass or colorful milkshake straw. Add some toppings along the brim of the glass to give it some #foodporn flare.

The #proteinshakes hashtag on Instagram has over 100,000 posts. It may just be a placebo, but it gets you to drink it. Next time you make your own, try making it look good enough to drink.

Photo by Pixabay

2. Keep it Chilled

If you have just worked out or are soon planning to, you are going to need something to quench your thirst. Nothing is more refreshing than a nice ice-cold drink. Use cold water when making your drink to get this effect. You can also chill it in the fridge or freezer to achieve its prime temperature for consumption.

Add a few ice cubes to keep it cool until the very end. Experiment with the temperature of your shakes to find what you enjoy best. You could even try it warm if you are feeling adventurous!

Photo by Pixabay

3. Dilute it

The strength of the flavor can be what puts many people off. You can add more water to tone down the strong flavors normally present. Adding less powder is another way to achieve the same result. You might also find that the smoother, thinner consistency of the drink makes it easier to drink.

Many recommend using 3/4th or even half of the normal powder measurement. It is up to you to find the perfect ratio of powder to water to make your shakes more delicious.

Photo by Pixabay

4. Use Milk Instead

Try using milk instead of your typical water in your shakes. The added milk can enhance the flavor as well as the consistency. Soy milk, almond milk, coconut milk, and even yogurt can be used too. Flavored varieties of these will add to the improvement of the flavor. If you are lactose-sensitive or intolerant, any lactose-free alternatives should also work.

If you are unsure about trying this tip, start by adding a little bit of milk to your normal recipe. If you like the result, continue adding more or swap it out completely.

Photo by Pixabay

5. Drink Your Favorite Flavor

Do you prefer chocolate or vanilla? If you like chocolate, look for a chocolate-flavored drink mix to try. If you like, vanilla keep it simple with the classic. You can always add extras like chocolate syrups or vanilla extract to give an additional tasty kick. This tip allows you to even make a strawberry-flavored drink with strawberry syrup.

Create medleys of your favorite flavors with different additives to your drink. Mix it up daily to wake up your taste buds and never get bored.

Photo by Pixabay

6. Make it Sweet

Adding sugar or other sweeteners can make your shakes more delicious, especially for those of us with a sweet tooth. Brown sugar or honey can be used as other options if you do not want to use normal table sugar. The right kind of stevia can be added for a healthier sweetener option.

Natural stevia will always be a healthier option than stevia which has been chemically processed. Just try not to go overboard with it and make it more sugar than the original powder! Making an overly sweet drink will lower the nutritional value of your shake.

Photo by Pixabay

7. Add Peanut Butter

Include a little bit of peanut butter in your mixture to up the tastiness. Peanut butter contains a lot of the nutrients we need. This is why it is an important ingredient used in Project Peanut Butter to fight extreme malnutrition. Whether you use a chocolate or vanilla-flavored base, you will end up with peanut butter cup goodness! This simple addition will take the flavor to the next level. For an option that is lower in calories and fat, try it with peanut butter powder.

Peanut butter powder is just a powder made from peanuts that have been pressed to remove the oil and some fats. If you are conscious about the amount of oil or calories you consume, try this option instead.

Photo by Pixabay

8. DIY it

If you just can not seem to make it work with everything you have tried, why not make your own? The flexibility in controlling exactly which ingredients go into your drink gives you the freedom to make it just the way you like it! You can start with a base like dry milk powder, which is packed with many important essential nutrients.

If there are any nutrients that you tend to be low in, supplement them. For example, if you are low in iron, try adding iron-rich foods. Experiment with different ingredients for thickness, flavor, and texture until you find your perfect homemade powder drink mix!

Photo by Pixabay

9. Delicious Fruity Smoothie

If you are into smoothies, try putting a fruity spin on your next drink. Fruits like bananas are a popular choice that goes well with the normal flavor of the shakes. Using frozen bananas is a great way to add some flavor while keeping that classic smoothie texture. It is as simple as adding your favorite fruit combos from smoothie recipes. Strawberry banana smoothies become protein-packed strawberry banana shakes.

You can even add in some fresh veggies for an additional nutrition boost. Combining this tip with some of the others will give you a shake so good, that you will be left wondering if it is your workout drink at all.

Photo by Pixabay

10. Turn Your Shake into a CAKE!

Okay, maybe not a cake specifically. Adding the powder mix to your other homemade treats can be a clever way to sneak in the benefits that you need. The powder can be used in place of other ingredients in many baking recipes.

Try a one-third cup of the powder for every cup of normal flour used. You can even try substituting only some of the flour until you get used to baking with the new powder. Using the powder in no-bake recipes may be a good way to start easing your way into this tip. Make sure that your recipe can take flour substitutes, then experiment to your heart’s content!

Photo by Pixabay

11. Add More Protein

If all else fails, you can rely on this final tip. Adding more protein and other nutrients to your recipe will increase its nutritional density. Making it more nutrient-rich means that you will need to drink less of it to get the same benefits. Find food that is high in the necessary nutrients to add to your mix. Some examples already mentioned are dry milk powder, various milk alternatives, and yogurt.

Nuts like almonds, pistachios, cashews, and of course peanuts are also rich in these things. Oats are a healthy grain that is compatible and will also help you stay full longer. If you simply can not bear the flavor of your workout drink, load it up with nutrients and drink it in smaller doses.


You’ve learned various ways to enhance the taste of your protein shake, from visual appeal to flavor boosters like peanut butter and fruits. Remember to keep your shake chilled, dilute it for a smoother texture, and experiment with different ingredients to find your favorite combination. Whether you prefer a sweet treat or a protein-packed cake, there are endless possibilities to make your shake more enjoyable.

Now it’s time to put these tips into action and create a protein shake that not only fuels your body but also delights your taste buds. Mix, blend, and sip your way to a delicious and satisfying drink that complements your fitness routine. Cheers to enjoying every sip of your upgraded protein shake!


How can I improve the taste of my protein shake visually?

To enhance the visual appeal, try garnishing with fresh fruit slices or mint leaves. Using a transparent glass and layering different colored ingredients can also make your protein shake look more enticing.

What is the best way to keep my protein shake chilled?

For a refreshing drink, blend your protein shake with ice cubes or use a refrigerated shaker bottle. You can also freeze fruits like bananas or berries beforehand and add them to your shake for a naturally cold boost.

Can I dilute my protein shake without compromising its benefits?

Yes, you can dilute your protein shake by adding more liquid like water or coconut water. This helps adjust the consistency to your preference while maintaining the essential nutrients and benefits of the shake.

How can I healthily sweeten my protein shake?

Opt for natural sweeteners like honey, maple syrup, or stevia instead of refined sugar. Adding ripe bananas, dates, or a dash of vanilla extract can also enhance the sweetness without compromising on healthiness.

Is it possible to turn my protein shake into a dessert-like treat?

Yes, transform your protein shake into a delectable dessert by blending in ingredients like cocoa powder, almond butter, or Greek yogurt. Experiment with spices like cinnamon or toppings such as crushed nuts for a decadent twist.